A Not-So-Joyful Noise

I come from a family of musicians. It’s a great way to grow up, but a problem we used to often encounter is that we could not turn off that side of ourselves in church. Some of you know what I’m talking about: The band starts to play, the worship leader opens their mouth and BAM—they sing a note that is nowhere near the right key. The musician in me inwardly cringes as the worship leader attempts to try to find the melody of the song ... and fails. I know this is worship time, but I and my family can't help but give each other looks every time the singers mess up their harmonies or the drummer gets a little "too happy" on those drums.

It is often a challenge for church music directors to find willing volunteers who not only want to give up their time but actually possess musical skill. They are often left to scramble, sometimes going outside their church membership to hire other singers and musicians to come in. Just how important is musicianship to the worship experience? What attitude should singers and musicians carry when in church?

Depending on what type of church you go to, the allotted worship time can be from 15 minutes to over an hour long in more charismatic churches. Regardless of how much prominence musical worship is given in your church services, it is up to those in charge to provide the right atmosphere for those to enter into God’s presence and leave behind the worries of the week. Worship should be a time of reverence, but commonly we settle into a pattern of familiarity with the chosen songs, the A-A-B-A structure or the calming voice of the worship leader as they invite the congregation to participate. It can easily become a ritual lacking any spiritual significance.

Yes, church music directors and praise team leaders should strive to make great music unto the Lord—the Bible says that whatever we do, we should work at it with all our hearts (Colossians 3:23-24)—but they also should understand the hearts of their musicians are more important than how many vocal runs they can produce. Worship teams are so much more effective when the love for God is evident on their faces. As I’ve heard someone say, they are not worship leaders, they are lead worshippers. When praise teams are more concerned with putting on a solid performance than with joining in worship with the congregation, there is a problem. Church is supposed to be a community, not a business. You can always work on improving someone’s musicality, but they have to come already prepared with the right spirit to worship.

We can get picky over whether our church chooses hymns over the "light-rock feel" of Chris Tomlin. But it all comes down to making a personal choice to look past the music and focus on what you are actually singing about. A song that used to have no meaning for me was Matt Redman’s “Blessed Be Your Name.” I had sung that song in church for years and thought it was pretty boring musically. However, at a service I recently attended, the worship leader explained the lyrical content. The song says, Blessed be Your name / when the sun’s shining down on me, and then the next verse says, Blessed be Your name / on the road marked with suffering. Oh, wait, so this song is about praising God when things are going your way, as well as when you are in the midst of intense suffering? It’s about being able to say, “Yes, Lord, I will worship You. I will bless Your name no matter what my circumstances." That is a message we all need to take in. Now when I hear that song in church, it has renewed meaning for me; the music does not matter because I found a way to connect with the song no matter how proficient the musicians are.

When I was 15, the youth pastor of our church said something that has stuck with me ever since. He said that everything we do can be worship to God. The words “worship” and “music” have been tied together so permanently that people think worship time ends when the praise team leaves the stage. But when we pray, when we tell our friends about Jesus, when we tithe, we’re worshipping. Worship is anything that lifts up God’s name and praises Him. The way in which we live our lives every day should be an act of worship.

And it doesn’t matter how you worship, either. Not everyone is going to run around a church singing “Hallelujah!” and not everyone is gonna stand still with their hands at their sides. I love to lift my hands toward God when I’m singing, but I have friends who don’t do that—and that’s fine. It does not matter what you do when that time comes; what matters is where your heart is. Be present in the worship. Try (as hard as it can be) to focus on God and His awesomeness instead of how the girl playing the piano should probably be wearing pants from that angle. Blocking out the world (and its unseemly distractions) is part and parcel with being able to enter into the presence of God.

My family may exchange loaded glances from time to time, but when our focus quickly turns to worship, we are able to move on. If the music is actually inhibiting your ability to worship, you better check and see what it is you’re actually praising. Don’t make music your god. Change your circumstances in order to avoid being put off by anything that may hinder you. Maybe you will even have to purposely seek out a different church. Whatever your options, make the changes necessary to take your focus off the screechy soprano and put it where it belongs—on the King of Kings.

You Might Also Like

“Whatever you do, work at it with all your heart, as working for the Lord, not for human masters, since you know that you will receive an inheritance from the Lord as a reward. It is the Lord Christ you are serving.” Colossians 3:23-24 (NIV)

Tara Burke is earning her master’s degree in communication and culture, specializing in race representation and performance studies. A writer, singer and blogger, her main aim is to make relevant, progressive works of media and culture that point people to the love of Christ. She lives in Toronto, Ontario, in Canada. Follow her on Twitter @taradotwords or on Tumblr at taraburke.tumblr.com.



eric commented…

Great article! I have the opposite problem. I get distracted (and frustrated) when the worship sounds canned or over-produced. In fact, I've caught myself becoming rebellious or almost antagonistic in an environment where the worship leader promotes such an American Idol-influenced view of music. I want my worship to sound natural. I want to hear the missed notes. I want to know the people up front are human. I don't know, maybe it's my folk/grunge background. Maybe it's the Dave Grohl in me.

But, it's my obstacle and something I've been dealing with whether on stage or off. Sometimes I have to just sit with my eyes closed and pray the words back to God.


Tydunham commented…

I've been leading worship for quite some time now, and when I was an assistant to the worship pastor he and I had this discussion many times - probably biweekly.

There are congregation members who by all accounts cannot sing a note, and somehow they are the loudest in a room of 300. But when I'm on stage, they honestly sound the most beautiful. I love hearing them sing their hearts out; they are probably aware that they're not great singers, but they're giving it all to God anyway. It warms my heart.

But I think the article ran past Colossians 3:23-4 too fast. It IS important that whatever we do, we do it with all our hearts - no buts. So when a band is having a difficult morning, I have to ask: did they not allow enough time for rehearsal? Has the worship leader sprung a new song on them? Is the guitarist neglecting to tune his guitar? Is anyone in the band actually listening to one another? Or is the guy at the soundboard just playing with his iPhone?

Mistakes will always happen, such as the occasional wrong chord or bad vocal key (You'd laugh if you knew how often I forgot to change my capo before singing the next song). But when bigger problems are happening - like the guitarist and the pianists are fighting to be the lead instrument while the bassist is offering no rhythm help for the novice drummer - there needs to be correcting.

A worshiper can have the purest heart, but that doesn't mean pride will never be an issue. And when pride is on the stage, it becomes evident to those (s)he's trying to lead. And that leads to distraction. And when the worshipers become too distracted to worship, then it just becomes music.

While I agree that first and foremost the heart is the most important thing for a worship musician to master, I've seen too many band members use it as an argument to skip practice or to just all around not give their best effort at bettering their talents for God.

All too often I've seen worship pastors throw whoever they can find on the stage because they're low on musicians that week. The quality of worship reflects this. I'm all for giving novice musicians the chance to worship on stage, but only when they are at a suitable place to keep up. The worship service is not about their need to become better musicians; it's about a community worshiping God. The smartest thing I've seen a worship pastor do is lead the congregation with just himself and the piano, because he knew the only other alternative was to make the worship suffer for the sake of having a few more pulses on the stage.



davebytheriver commented…

I'd say that this is really the same struggle showing itself in a different way. We all default to wanting the worship experience to look like us - whether that means we want it perfectly slick and seamless or we want it rough around the edges. If it doesn't resemble our own ideal, wherever that ideal stems from, we tend to judge it as somehow less Godly.

And I'm not dogging you for that because I struggle in the much the same way. My "ideal" is great musicianship, but if the worship leader has frosted tips or a rock star mentality, it's tough for me to perceive it as genuine. And I also get super annoyed when the drums are mixed as though they're a necessary evil rather than the glue that holds it all together (read: too quiet).


Rhonda Hernandez commented…

Years ago, I was in our organ/hymnal church's mini-orchestra (I play piano). My daughter was one of the flutists, my son was on clarinet. I'll never forget the time when we were supposed to play the closing piece after the benediction, and, through a nightmarish misunderstanding, half of us played one hymn, half of us played another. It didn't take more than 2 measures to realize that something was horribly wrong! We all looked at each other as it got worse, and finally just stopped playing one by one.

The effect was that of a deflating bagpipe...hysterical when I think of it now, but absolutely mortifying at the time!

Enjoyed the article.


Meaghan Smith


Meaghan Smith commented…

Whereas they tend to be quite costly, it's definitely worth the investment, as they final a very very long time, and add value to your house.


Please log in or register to comment

Log In