4 Myths Christians Need to Stop Believing About Depression

It's time for the Church to get real about depression.

“True believers don’t suffer from depression.”

His false statement rang in my ear like a noisy gong, and then hung in the air like smoke, waiting to be cleared away. I wasn’t exactly sure how this conversation had started, but one thing led to another and I here I was with this visitor and a small group of men and women discussing the existence of depression among Christians.

It would have been a hard conversation for anyone to have, but for me, it was even harder still.  Because little did this visitor know that I was only now emerging from the terrible pit of depression myself. Little did he know that for me, this conversation was personal, because I felt like I’d just been to hell and back. Little did he know that my heart had wrestled and my body had collapsed under the pressure of depression.

As a counselor, this was a conversation I was glad to be a part of. For over a decade, I’ve worked with men, women, children and teens struggling with mild to severe depression. I’ve seen firsthand the pain and paralysis it can bring. But I’ve also experienced it in my own life. I know the sinking quicksand that can drain your body, burden your heart and eat away at your mind.

It breaks my heart to hear the myths and lies that Christians believe about depression and the shame that can be felt surrounding this topic. As I’ve interacted with more and more people on this topic, I’ve noticed that there are a few false ideas that continue to be perpetuated among believers:

Depression is a Faith Issue.

As believers, we are never promised a pain-free, disease-free, struggle-free life. But we are promised a Savior, A Comfortor and a Friend. 

Like the visitor had falsely said many Christians buy into the idea that “True believers don’t suffer from depression.” 

I think this is the worst of all the lies, because not only is it false, but it’s antithesis of the entire message of Christ. As believers, we are never promised a pain-free, disease-free, struggle-free life. But we are promised a Savior, A Comfortor and a Friend. 

I look back at the hardest moments I have faced with depression and I see Jesus right by my side. I remember crying out one night and feeling all alone, and just then, God’s presence overwhelmed me in that moment, just when I needed it the most.  

Depression has nothing to do with a lack of faith. In fact, for me, it has been the catalyst for even deeper faith. Because some days, in the hardest moments, faith was the only thing I had.

Depression Can be Prayed Away.

I prayed more during the days and months when my depression was worst than I ever did in my entire life. But my depression didn’t magically disappear.

I believe in prayer, and I believe in a God who can heal all things—in fact, I genuinely believe it was His hand that lifted my depression. But freedom from depression requires prayer and treatment. Whether in the form of support, therapy or medication, as believers we have to have a “next steps” approach as we interact with people struggling with depression.

God has given us wisdom, and loads of research, to help us understand the multi-faceted disease of depression. It’s time for us to pray—but to also be prepared.

Depression isn’t Physical.

Just as we would never shame a cancer patient or a diabetic for their hurting bodies, we need to shift our perspective to see depression as a struggle of the body.  Only then will we be able to treat it in a proper way.  

Depression is a disease of the body that in turn impacts our emotions, our thoughts and even our spirit. There are many causes to depression, and whether it’s rooted in trauma, hormones or stress, it almost always affects our body.  

Our perspective of Depression needs to change so that we can learn to embrace and support those in it, instead of pushing them away.

Depression Shouldn’t Be Talked About. 

Though I still see hints of this myth among Christians, I am grateful to see this myth slowly dying in the Church.  There is no shame in feeling depressed, and we should learn to talk about it, preach about it and sing about it when it’s all said and done.

Scripture is filled with passages of men and women who have struggled through the pit of depression and their response was to cry out!

Scripture is filled with passages of men and women who have struggled through the pit of depression and their response was to cry out! Crying out is always the first step to healing—because depression is a disease that thrives in isolation. It wants to pull us into the prison of loneliness, where it can break us down in weakness.  

You Might Also Like

By talking about depression, we slowly begin loosening its grip—allowing us to move in the direction of treatment, support and healing.

My deepest prayer is that as a body of believers, our attitudes would shift and our hearts would change as we work through this important issue. May we create an environment where we embrace those who are struggling and in pain rather than push them away. May we learn to be transparent—but more so, to accept the transparency of those around us.  

Because at the end of the day, our weakness will always, always point us to the one who can make us strong. And isn’t that what Christianity is really about?

This article was originally published at truelovedates.com.

Top Comments

Luke Worle


Luke Worle replied to David Cochran's comment

David the primary reason I called the writer and her piece ''brave'' was because many of us have walked the same walk where Christian circles attempt to dissect the causes for our depression. With myself, I had to weather the most unbelievably insensitive comments, such as ''Well Job suffered more then you and still bowed before God''..or this doozy...''Stop being selfish''...Oh did I mention that that zinger came on the heels of me finding out my mother was near death and losing my job in the same day? But for simply cathartic-ally feeling the full weight of the moment it was misconstrued as sin/selfish/human error. Sorry. I do not subscribe to the dogmatic compartmentalizing that everything has a spiritual cause only full stop. We are spiritual beings but are also organic beings. This has nothing to do with a progressive secularist agenda, but simply a system of checks and balances in how we look at the causes and deciding factors for depression. Organic imbalances exist in the body as in the mind. Is a diabetic at fault for low blood sugar due to sin and lack of faith? Do we really need to split hairs and determine what causes people's sufferings or do we all need to fundamentally admit that the church all too many times conveniently and superficially stigmatizes all mental illness as caused by lack of relationship with God (or sin) without taking any time to look into other factors as well? The author's point in this article is to simply address the lack of balance in how the Church oftentimes looks at depression. Maybe you have had different experiences then some of us, but that doesn't mean that scapegoating ''sin'' or ''attitude'' as the allegded culprit to depression doesn't always exist. As in everything, balance, truth, light, patience and understanding go a long way. Flippant, fiinger pointing insensitive handling of people's suffering is a primary reason why I have seen many Christians in emotional turmoil give up on the church. Some have ended their lives. Nobody took the time-or gave the grace- to come down from their own pulpit and to stop playing judge. Her article indeed is brave as is her determination to be vulnerable once again. I respect that.

Trista Sue Price


Trista Sue Price commented…

As someone who suffers from hypothyroidism, depression and anxiety are part of the package. Thankfully, there is treatment for my condition and I am on the road to recovery. But there was a time before I was diagnosed when nothing could pull me out of my deep depression. I was going to church, praying, reading my bible, had counseling with a close pastor friend, and I was even a leader in our youth ministry. But every night, I would lay in bed for hours until I finally cried myself to sleep (usually not till at least 2am) and there were days where I wouldn't get up until 2 or 3 in the afternoon. It was horrible. I gained weight, my relationships suffered, and my health was continuously going downhill.
It is so refreshing to see people out there who know that depression is a REAL condition that should be treated with respect, not just another excuse for a hypochondriac. I would give anything to feel like my normal self again, but I know I'm on my way and God has always been there, loving me and guiding me through. :)


Tania Antoniuk


Tania Antoniuk commented…

Depression can come as a result of many factors: 1) trying to be perfect or excellent and not achieving that goal 2) being overwhelmed and disappointed by someone turning on you - a Dr. Jekyl and Mr. Hyde personality 3) brainwashing or someone trying to control you and slowing slowing gaining ground without you realizing how bad it is getting. SINCERE PRAYER TO JESUS HELPS, ESPECIALLY WHEN WE MAKE IT SIMPLE AND JUST SAY HELP OR I CAN'T HANDLE THESE THOUGHTS, I WANT TO LEARN TO BE POSITIVE. Counselling with a sincere and loving Christian who knows the Word and that God is loving and will never leave you nor forsake you is one of the best HEALING METHODS FOR DEPRESSION.

Ted Larson


Ted Larson commented…

Thank you for posting this story. I have heard all three of these myths, have been through terrible depression and have at more than one time, been suicidal. I was blessed to have friends who encouraged me to get help. I, too have come away with a deeper and more unshakable faith in my Master. Thank you again for this story.

Ruth Folger


Ruth Folger commented…

This is good, however the author did not mention that genetics can definetley play a role. My personal feeling is that many who suffer from it probably have some sort of genetic predisposition to it. The traumas, stresses, and whatever life deals us just bring it to the forefront. Am glad to read things like this, many Christians do not know what/how to address depression. This is too bad, b/c those who are in great need will turn away from church, rather than towards it, for comfort and support.

Merle Hexum


Merle Hexum commented…

It's hard to believe that a Christian could be so cruel and critical of a person suffering any type of affliction, but I'm sure there's a few out there who lack the compassion necessary to encourage someone going through a difficult time. We need to be people who point to the answer rather than one's who focus on the problem.

Psalm 34:19 Many are the afflictions of the righteous: but the Lord deliverers him out of them all.

It doesn't matter whether it's cancer or depression, heart disease or anxiety, the Lord delivers us from them all. I've never personally met a Christian who's been critical of or condescending toward another Christian who was going through an affliction. I've heard about it, I've seen it on movies, but I've never witnessed firsthand where someone actually did that.

A greater problem, and one which is much more prevalent in the church, is seeing brothers and sisters believing thatsit's God's will for them to suffer with sickness, disease, and mental illness. Christians who fail to fully embrace the covenant that we have with our Creator. There are actually believers (I use the word loosely here) out there who do not know that it's God's will to heal, all the time and every time. Believers who do no realize that healing is as much a part of our covenant as forgiveness of sins.

Psalm 103:2-3 Bless the Lord, O my soul, and forget not all his benefits: Who forgiveth all thine iniquities; who healeth all thy diseases;

Depression is an attack from the enemy, it's not a gift from God to draw us closer to Him, nor is it sent from Him to teach us some lesson. Satan bombards our minds with lies from the pit of hell. The author of this article is correct depression in that depression is not usually simply prayed away, but it's a start. We need to be aggressive and on the offense, it is we who choose for ourselves what are mind is going to think on.

We need to pull down the strong holds, cast down those imaginations, and take every thought captive. We not only need to take those thoughts from the enemy captive, but we need to replace them with what God says about us and constantly think and meditate on what He says.

Philippians 4:6-8 Do not be anxious or worried about anything, but in everything every circumstance and situation by prayer and petition with thanksgiving, continue to make your specific requests known to God. And the peace of God that peace which reassures the heart, that peace which transcends all understanding, that peace which stands guard over your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus is yours. Finally, believers, whatever is true, whatever is honorable and worthy of respect, whatever is right and confirmed by God’s word, whatever is pure and wholesome, whatever is lovely and brings peace, whatever is admirable and of good repute; if there is any excellence, if there is anything worthy of praise, think continually on these things center your mind on them, and implant them in your heart.

People with depression need meditation, not medication. God has has given us the victory, but we must take it, just like the Israelites needed to cast out the Giants and possess the land.

Ronnie Van Zant


Ronnie Van Zant commented…

YES! Thank you for sharing this, RELEVANT Magazine! I am fighting the stigma that mental illness and Christianity has together, and individually. Articles like this help that effort.

Please log in or register to comment

Log In