Vocation or Occupation

It’s the ageless question: “What should I do with my life?”

Countless books, blogs and sermons have been dedicated to the topic. John Piper told you not to waste it, and Rick Warren told you how to be purpose-driven in it. You have heard everything from “Jesus is the answer” to “You are the answer” and all things in between. Yet, most young people are increasingly more skeptical of such easy answers and believe it's probably not so simple as a 12-step process of a 40-day program.

At one time during your teenage years, you may have heard your guidance counselor say that your answer to the question, “If you could do anything, what would you do?” tells you what you were meant to do. It says something about what your passions are, where your interests lie, and what you’d be doing if you didn’t have to worry about paying the bills and other responsibilities. But most people struggle with the two—I call it the issue of vocation versus occupation.

The word “vocation” comes from the Latin vocare, which means “calling.” It suggests some grand purpose in your life, that there are unseen forces guiding you in making key decisions that will lead you to fulfilling your destiny. It has an air of grandeur and mystery to it. It sounds intentional and meaningful. After all, who doesn’t want to be summoned for something great?

Occupation, on the other hand, has the same root as the English word “occupy,” which we all know means “to take up space.” And that’s just what most occupations do—they take up your time, energy and (in some cases) your dignity. Whether it means flipping burgers, skydiving or serving as the assistant to the high school gym teacher, an occupation is not what you dreamed of doing when you grew up (for those of you who didn’t dream of skydiving for a living, shame on you). It is the equivalent of a “summer job” or whatever you might do to “just pay the bills.” It’s the thing you do to pass the time, while you dream of doing other things. While there is nothing particularly wrong with an occupation, there is nothing remarkable about it, either. One thing is certain: It cannot be mistaken for a vocation.

A few years ago, I was struggling with the two—occupation and vocation. I sensed my heart was leading me to live with reckless abandon, to pursue my dreams and passions, while my mind was telling me to live with careful reservation, pursuing a responsible and stable life in preparation for marriage. I was worried I was facing a crossroads in my life, and I was, quite frankly, anxious about “selling out.”

In a panic, I called my mentor. I can’t stress enough how important it is for young people to have coaches in their lives whom they trust to give candid, relevant feedback. I’m not just talking about a parent, professor or pastor (although, I suppose any one of those could fill such a role), but rather a trusted friend who hears your confessions and gets to speak into your life in a uniquely influential way. This kind of relationship takes a high degree of trust and grace to build and maintain, but once you have it, it’s invaluable. So, I went to my mentor and told him my dilemma.

Quite candidly, he responded, “Join the crowd.”

“What?!” I was incredulous.

“Actually,” he said. “I think you’re in a good place—struggling with what you could do and what you should do. It says a lot about your character, that you’re concerned about fulfilling your life’s calling and providing for your family. I feel bad for those who don’t struggle with the two.”

I ruminated on that for awhile, and it really struck me as profound. Join the crowd. That phrase changed the way I thought of what I had to do and what I loved doing. I had always believed if those two didn’t completely synchronize with one another that something was seriously wrong in my life.

You Might Also Like

But maybe that’s just how real life is—messy.

Maybe it's not a bad thing to struggle with the concepts of occupation and vocation. Maybe the real tragedy is in not struggling at all—in flaking out on your responsibilities for the sake of your “calling” or compromising your dream for the sake of security. Maybe those of us who don’t lose sleep over the idea of calling and living responsibly are indeed missing out.

Maybe you should join the crowd. But whatever you do, don’t just take up space.



stephante commented…

Le sigh.

This is so timely. I graduated last May with a B.S. in psychology. Long story short, I couldn't decide on a graduate program, and got engaged, so for those and other reasons decided to take a little time off from school and just let life simmer. Get some perspective. I got a job in an office, just some clerical work, nice and mindless to pass the time and help get ready for married life. The church happened last nite and we talked about Jonah and running from what God wants us to do...

I'm scared to do social work or counseling because I'm unprepared and underqualified and young. But I really feel that it is what I'm supposed to do. My fiance told me he'd rather me face those fears than lie to myself that I can be happy with what I'm doing now....

Oy vey.

Jeff Goins


Jeff Goins commented…

Yup. Tough stuff. Join the crowd. I recommend some kind of personal retreat to figure out this stuff. It requires a delicate balance of priorities, responsibility to others and God, and timing. Maybe a half day of silence or a weekend of prayer and fasting in the woods. Most of the people I have the utmost respect for do such a thing when they have to make a major decision. I try to follow their example.



Heather commented…

LMBO. I'm sorry I have to laugh at the fasting part on my behalf, because I'm a reactive hypoglycemic and if I don't eat... well... lets just say bad things happen. I just want to know why Christians throughout history feel the need to starve themselves in order to hear from God?? I just don't feel that measure is necessary.

And what happens when you have asked time and time again and you're still not getting any answers?



Heather commented…

And Jeff... we could start a campaign for the people who just plain suck at life!! LOL. Because as Relient K says "Failure is just a blessing in disguise."

Jeff Goins


Jeff Goins commented…

Thanks for the reply, Heather. I don't have a great rational argument for fasting, other than that Jesus modeled it and said in Matthew 6, "When you fast..." not, "IF you fast" and that I've seen it work. As far as what to do when God seems silent, I don't think that I have any advice better than that which has filled the pages of countless books. Best thing I can say is to press in, keep listening, and maybe try fasting...

PS I have a friend who is hypoglycemic and fasts a meal or fasts from most food, but eats small snacks to not pass out. The point is not the starvation, in my opinion, but the intentional setting aside of time and concentrating on God. If you're struggling to find answers, I recommend some sort of creative fast (may be best to just pray into it and see what you come up with on your own).

PPS Interesting idea about the club. It could be like the FAIL blog, but we could highlight our failed attempts at holiness. Ah, man, I just depressed myself.

Please log in or register to comment

Log In