A Not-So-Happy Fatherless Day

Why an epidemic of fatherlessness is one of our future’s greatest challenges.

In an average American classroom, chances are a third of the kids are living in a home without a father. This may not seem like a huge deal, but the effects of fatherless homes are significant and far-reaching: children without fathers are five times more likely to live in poverty and commit crime, nine times more likely to drop out of schools and 20 times more likely to end up in prison.

Giacomo Knox was part of that group of children growing up. He spent nearly 30 years wondering what happened to his father. His parents separated when he was just 4 years old, and his mother fled with him and his sister from New Jersey to Seattle because, she said, she was afraid of her husband.

Knox only heard of his father sporadically after that, usually through negative comments from his mother and her side of the family. There was never a stepfather in the picture, although some of his mom’s boyfriends over the years tried and failed to act as surrogate dads for him.

“I was a precocious child and a lot smarter than I should have been at that age,” says Knox, now 40 and a resident of Los Angeles. “Originally, her brief boyfriends tried but gave up because most men won’t date a woman who has kids, especially two kids. I was immediately rejecting any real attention because they’d set a pattern of leaving anyway.”

Knox certainly isn’t alone. An estimated one out of three American households with children are single-parent, and usually mother-only, homes. That’s an estimated 25 million fatherless kids. The epidemic of fatherlessness causes a strain on young lives and leaves many young men with the burden of trying to figure out how to be a good man without any solid examples to look to.

Author Donald Miller, best known for his popular book Blue Like Jazz, is one man who experienced a fatherless childhood and now works to increase awareness of the importance of fathers. A native of Houston, he now works in Portland, Ore., as the founder of The Mentoring Project—formerly known as The Belmont Foundation—a nonprofit group aiming to recruit 10,000 mentors through 1,000 churches across America.

Miller has become notable in the mentor movement because of his book To Own a Dragon: Reflections on Growing Up Without a Father, in which he recounts the impact on his life from his father leaving when he was 2 years old. As an adult, he has managed to find his father, and believes that attempting a reconciliation is well worth the effort.

“When you grow up without a dad, there’s an emotional instability that is transferred,” Miller says. “Humans get validation externally, not internally. They tend to take blame for themselves, and it affects their self-esteem. I grew up with all the ramifications of growing up without a dad. The research is out there and it’s not good.

“I see it as the lead domino in a whole litany of problems,” Miller says. “Statistics show kids are more likely to stay in school, off drugs and have no [teen] pregnancy if both parents are there. That means fewer abortions, too. Ninety-four percent of people in prison are men, and 85 percent without fathers.”

However, some people who grow up in fatherless homes, like Miller and Knox, do go on to forge solid, productive lives. The most famous current example lives in the White House. President Barack Obama’s father largely abandoned him as a young child, leading him to engage in an adult quest that led to his best-selling memoir, Dreams of My Father, and the attendant acclaim that helped launch his political career.

Yet even as he’s attained the status of “most powerful leader on earth,” Obama has not forsaken his youthful hardships and has made strong father-child relationships the basis of a ubiquitous public service announcement campaign currently running on television in conjunction with the website Fatherhood.gov.

In the PSA, Obama says: “To be a good father is the most important job in a man’s life. ... Things get busy, and sometimes we all fall short. But the smallest moments can have the biggest impact on a child’s life. Take time to be a dad today.”

According to Sheila Thornton, a licensed clinical social worker who is site director at the 80-year-old agency Foothill Family Service in Pasadena, Calif., there are some often overlooked truths about the important role of fathers in people’s lives.

“Because of biology, women give birth to children, so there’s more attachment or a special attachment,” Thornton says. “Not having a father not only hugely impacts the child but the family. Children benefit from the nurturing of [both the] mother and the father, so it’s a challenge.”

Thornton also points out the financial aspects of a fatherless home—the added stress and difficult realities of mothers trying to raise kids on one income and, if they need a second job to get by, with less time to nurture their children and put food on the table.

“The role of a dad is a really important and unique role that is supported by the role of mom, and it impacts kids throughout their lives,” Thornton says. “That doesn’t mean kids can’t grow up and be successful, but it puts an extra burden on the parent that’s left. I think when there’s a parent missing in the home, or even if the dad’s there and not present in the child’s life, that kid grows up not knowing the importance of a dad in a child’s life.”

This can set a destructive cycle in which boys whose fathers disappear rarely learn the responsibility of sticking around to raise the children they have later in life. But the lack of a father in the home doesn’t solely affect boys: Research has found that teen girls without fathers are twice as likely to be involved in early sexual activity and seven times more likely to get pregnant as an adolescent.

“It impacts children no matter what their gender,” Thornton says. “Some kids do well because they simply force themselves to deal with the circumstances, while others do well because they have more family support.”

Miller recognizes that women can also experience father issues. In the new introduction of To Own a Dragon—which registered so strongly with readers that it was re-released in April under the title Father Fiction—he writes: “Women suffer from father issues too, obviously. They may suffer more. ... Women tend to become victims when they grow up without good fathers. Men tend to become oppressors.“

As an adult, Miller turned to writing to help work out some of his problems—the result being Dragon. While working on the book was cathartic, he draws strength now from his work with The Mentoring Project. So far, the group has developed mentorships for 150 Portland-area youths in nine churches, and the group’s more ambitious national goals are due to launch in the coming year.

“It’s a relational problem so you need a relational solution—guys who are mentors, speak affirmation and truth into their lives. I keep those men around personally, and it’s been an invaluable help,” Miller says. “Thankfully, there’s a trend toward fathers staying present. We have a masculinity crisis in this country, but it’s simple: being there, providing, being emotionally vulnerable and open. The Hollywood model of manhood works against us in so many ways. The mentoring program I founded shows that if each church mentors 10 to 20 men without fathers, you can shut down prisons in 20 years. The only institution that can do something significant about this is the Church.”

This article originally appeared in RELEVANT magazine.



Holly T commented…

I feel that what was said in this comment is EXACTLY why so many articles on this subject rub me the wrong way. Many people with 2 parents end up screwed up. Many people with single parent homes end up healthy adults with the ability to have meaningful relationships and a darn good amount of self worth. I DO believe that a good father (father figure) is so very important, it's ridiculous to suggest it is not. That being said, many of the articles I've read on the subject sounds more like a plea, or a warning, to those being irresponsible, rather than a realistic view of what's possible. Becoming a father, then bailing, is more or less the action of someone who has severe and deep-rooted issues with their role as a human. Now consider that same exact person deciding (or being coerced) to "stick it out" for as long as possible... That also has real potential to cause many problems within the family. Hence, those who grew up in two-parent households, and are not mentally/emotionally healthy adults. Of course it is very challenging being a single parent in a single parent household! It's even HARDER being a single parent in a two-parent household.
Daniel Townsend, if that article is available, I'd like to read it please.


Holly T commented…

Randaman, my heart goes out to you and no doubt God has some serious plans for you. You've been thru hell and I hope you find healing.


danieltownsend commented…

Hi Holly. Thanks for your feedback.

I've created a blog and posted the article there: http://youknowyoushouldwriteab...


Marguerite123 commented…

My son is spending another fathers day without his 4 yr. old son because his wife moved out of state and is making false allegations about my son and our family and the courts have to investigate any allegations....the only way this beast of a woman can live out of state is if she can prove it is a danger to the child to live in the homestate.....so she continues to make false allegations knowing the CSA will get involved and he would have to have supervised visitation and be interviewed by a physciatrist with his son ( which he did and the doctor heard the child say his family made him say the bad things, which show he was coached) but nevertheless, the wheels of justice turn very SLOWLY to say the least and my son has gone as long as 8 mos. without seeing his child....the laws have to change....all a woman has to do is say a man said anything and they immediately cease visitation until all the organizations get involved......meanwhile the poor loving father is left without seeing his child, but he MUST pay his child support and the separation becomes longer and longer without seeing his child....I say they should still let a father visit with his child even if it is supervised visitation because they must keep the bond of father/son going or the child will eventually forget his father.....the courts need to change the laws regarding false allegations, it's too easy for a woman to just invent a story and then we are left without our child/grandchildren due to the beast of a woman who is making it all up....parental alienation is a crime but these vile people are getting away with it......amen....I pray for justice.....to all the fathers out there I say STAY STRONG and God bless you.

Darryl Franks


Darryl Franks commented…

Critically damaging to the prospects of a thriving economy, Cries the Night to Sleep is a 39-page journal that uncovers the bleak subject. From the extremes made survivable to the failures and embarrassments of what has become later-day statistics, the topic has made this world a harder place to live in. To view website please go to www.criesthenighttosleep.com
Thank you, Darryl Franks

Please log in or register to comment

Log In