When Life Doesn't Go as Planned

Finding hope in the disappointment.

A lament of David: “I am poured out like water and all my bones are out of joint. My heart has turned to wax; it has melted away within me. My strength is dried up like [broken pottery] and my tongue sticks to the roof of my mouth; you lay me in the dust of death” (Psalm 22:14-18, NIV).

Most of us like to plan out our lives. We strategize about colleges, majors, relationships, careers, jobs, houses, spouses, kids and so forth. We have these dreams and goals that lead to success, happiness and what we imagine as an ideal existence.

But what happens when life doesn’t go according to all our carefully laid plans?

Our hearts break. Nothing makes sense anymore. Dreams disappear like smoke and seem impossibly out of reach. We lose control. We lose our faith. Doubt creeps in and other people’s prosperity only seems to taunt us rather than cause joy. Then we try really, desperately hard to get things back on track. We work and stress and plot and do everything we possibly can to find hope and a glimpse that at some point this pain will end.

Do you ever notice that churches tend to have people share their testimonies when all the crap they’ve been through has concluded? These wonderful men and women of faith are on the other side. They’ve seen God do amazing things and can proclaim, “This struggle was all part of God’s plan.”

It’s truly awesome. We should share our triumphs. But does anyone else ever feel sort-of worse after testimonies? I mean, all I want to do is look back and see what amazing things God worked out. However, I’m completely stuck in the middle of pain, mess, heartache, defeat, disappointment and situations that just won’t change no matter how much I want them to.

I want to hear from people like me. People who don’t know how things will turn out.

What "the middle" reveals

My husband and I lost a pregnancy a little over a year ago after three years of infertility and no successful treatments since. We’ve decided to foster-adopt a child through our state’s Department of Children and Families. As we wait for our license to be approved, we know we could wait even longer for a child. We could risk losing a child placed with us back to their biological parents ... ones who in the past have abused or neglected them. We could be in court for years to even be able to adopt.

Being stuck in the middle of pain, waiting and tentative hope is a hard place to be. It is.

There’s much emphasis put on reaching goals in life, but as I experience both success and immense failure, I’m coming to realize there is tremendous value to being stuck in the middle of difficulties.

We can learn some incredibly sweet, freeing, heart-changing and life-altering things in the middle.

We find out who God really is.

And we find out who we really are. Suffering gets straight to the point of all this painful, stretching, creative, gut-wrenching and radiant living. It shows us what we’re made of and it teaches us this amazing thing about being human; that we’re designed as relational beings. We can connect deeply with each other and there is great power in that connect-ability.

The one thing we can control

“Two are better than one. ... If either of them falls down one can help the other up. But pity anyone who falls and has no one to help them up” (Ecclesiastes 4:9-10, NIV).

Here’s the thing: We can’t hold one another up if we’re all pretending things are fine.

As I have become more honest about my struggles, an amazing thing happens. The very act of being vulnerable provides a kind of implicit permission for others to admit they are going through hardships as well. There is almost an immediate sort of healing when you share; when things get real.

Because we’re all in the middle of something. And doesn’t it help to not feel so alone?

I think God’s plan is at work in the middle of our messes more powerfully than at any other time. Which is good because I feel like most of life is spent stuck slogging through something or other. God loves to show up and teach us things when we’re slogging. He designed us to become somehow better through all the pain we endure and specifically created us to find comfort in each other.

In Charlotte's Web by E.B. White, there is this wonderful scene between Charlotte the spider, who is nearing the end of her life, and her friend Wilbur the pig. Charlotte tells Wilbur, “You have been my friend. That in itself is a tremendous thing. I wove my webs for you because I liked you. After all, what's a life, anyway? We're born, we live a little while, we die. A spider's life can't help being something of a mess, with all this trapping and eating flies. By helping you, perhaps I was trying to lift up my life a trifle. Heaven knows anyone's life can stand a little of that.”

You Might Also Like

A man or woman’s life can’t help but be something of a mess.

The one thing we all can control though is how we respond to being in the middle. When God seems distant, we can choose to have faith that He’s walking with us. When pain becomes suffocating, we can decide to reach out and share what’s happening with someone. When everything seems grim and never-ending, we can choose to delight in a quiet moment, a deep breath ... maybe a chocolate cookie. And when our hearts still can’t let go of wanting that certain outcome, we can choose to realize that no matter what happens we are of immense worth to God and to those who love us. Despite how things might turn out.

We’re all together in the middle and God is there too. Even if things are not fine, somehow they are.

Melissa Kircher, along with her husband Jake, write about relationships and marriage at www.holymessofmarriage.com. You can also follow them on Twitter @marriageismessy. Melissa recently gave her testimony about being in the middle at Grace Community Church of New Canaan, Conn., which you can listen to here.



Anonymous commented…

Really enjoyed this, i love that we are starting to see that there is suffering in our journey. For so long we have had messages laced with entitlement, if something has gone wrong then you have sinned, and prosperity. I am not a hellfire and damnation sort of guy, but having lived a life that has seen its share of trials, I have found that this times of suffering are times that draw me close, humble me, and deepen my relationship. I haven't found them to be an indicator of my spiritual (or lack there of) walk. Thanks for sharing, this is great!



Jenksym commented…

Everywhere in Scripture you see that while the choosing, the calling and the annointing are all celebrated; God is truly encountered in the wilderness. The wilderness ISthe middle!


Anonymous commented…

This is a beautiful reality: God comforts us IN our afflictions. Thank you for this article. I will pass this on, because it is true and lovely and we are to dwell on these things. Peace to you and my prayers for your family.

Matt Hendrickson


Matt Hendrickson commented…

Really speaks to me with stuff I'vehad going on lately. It was finally over this weekend during worship time that I really felt that God was reaching out to me. It got to the point where I had to go for prayer and just let peoplein on how I was feeling. Since that night I know that He has been waiting for me to getout of His way to begin the healing. I've known God was always there, but this week He's really started to move. Now I just need to trust enough to know that He knows what he is doing during this time of struggle.


janedoeeastcoast commented…

Wow, this came at such a great time. I went through a seriously hard break up and the day I told my best friend, she told me that I needed to up and move on from the four end hard break up. It's so true that there is nothing left for those in the middle.

I just told my friend that I've been lying for over a year and I am still hurt about it. She hasn't heard me mention it in a long time so she assumed I was all patched up. I wish life really was that easy because I've been trying.I know I will get there. But admittedly, I'm in pain. I too am somewhere in the middle. I'm not sure when the feeling will subside but like the author said, I've tried so hard to control getting over it. I'm learning that Rome wasn't built in one day and some things do take time. I am learning to be patient with my heart.

Please log in or register to comment

Log In